You have skipped the navigation, tab for page content

How will the Panthers respond to the dark days that have enveloped their club in recent weeks when they take on their western Sydney rivals on Sunday afternoon?

The Panthers enter the 2019 Telstra Premiership rated among the top echelon of sides. They'll be determined to put a tough couple of weeks behind them come game day, but achieving such plans is often easier said than done.

The Eels, on the other hand, have had a smooth pre-season. They'll be eager to snare an early scalp following a largely disappointing 2018.

Parra led 14-0 after 30 minutes of the corresponding round one clash last year before the mountain men scored the final 24 points.

The first match of Ivan Cleary's second run as Penrith coach will be closely watched for many reasons. 

The Rundown

Team News

Panthers: In a string of positional changes announced an hour before kick-off, Moses Leota (prop) and Hame Sele (second row) have been added to the starting side, with Reagan Campbell-Gillard and Jack Hetherington to start on the bench. Sione Katoa (concussion) was ruled out on Saturday, with Wade Egan to start at hooker and Jarome Luai the new utility on the bench. As well as Katoa, Liam Martin dropped off the reserves bench 24 hours before kick-off. 

Eels: The Eels will start 1-17, with Josh Hoffman and Oregon Kaufusi the two men omitted an hour out from game time. Junior Paulo and Bevan French were the two men dropped off the bench 24 hours before kick-off.

Team Lists


  • Fullback for Panthers is number 1 Dylan Edwards
    Fullback for Eels is number 1 Clinton Gutherson
  • Winger for Panthers is number 2 Josh Mansour
    Winger for Eels is number 2 Maika Sivo
  • Centre for Panthers is number 3 Dean Whare
    Centre for Eels is number 3 Michael Jennings
  • Centre for Panthers is number 4 Waqa Blake
    Centre for Eels is number 4 Brad Takairangi
  • Winger for Panthers is number 5 Dallin Watene-Zelezniak
    Winger for Eels is number 5 Blake Ferguson
  • Five-Eighth for Panthers is number 6 James Maloney
    Five-Eighth for Eels is number 6 Dylan Brown
  • Halfback for Panthers is number 7 Nathan Cleary
    Halfback for Eels is number 7 Mitchell Moses


  • Prop for Panthers is number 8 James Tamou
    Prop for Eels is number 8 Daniel Alvaro
  • Hooker for Panthers is number 14 Wayde Egan
    Hooker for Eels is number 9 Reed Mahoney
  • Prop for Panthers is number 16 Moses Leota
    Prop for Eels is number 10 Tepai Moeroa
  • 2nd Row for Panthers is number 12 Isaah Yeo
    2nd Row for Eels is number 11 Shaun Lane
  • 2nd Row for Panthers is number 17 Hame Sele
    2nd Row for Eels is number 12 Marata Niukore
  • Lock for Panthers is number 13 James Fisher-Harris
    Lock for Eels is number 13 Nathan Brown


  • Interchange for Panthers is number 10 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
    Interchange for Eels is number 14 Will Smith
  • Interchange for Panthers is number 11 Jack Hetherington
    Interchange for Eels is number 15 Tim Mannah
  • Interchange for Panthers is number 15 Tyrell Fuimaono
    Interchange for Eels is number 16 Kane Evans
  • Interchange for Panthers is number 18 Jarome Luai
    Interchange for Eels is number 17 David Gower

Match Officials

  • Referee: Ashley Klein
  • Referee: Chris Butler
  • Touch Judge: Nick Beashel
  • Touch Judge: Matt Noyen
  • Senior Review Official: Steve Chiddy

Last updated:

Key match-up

Nathan Cleary v Mitchell Moses. This is Mitchell Moses' sixth year in the NRL. He has mixed periods of brilliance with others in which he has struggled for consistency. In this match he will take on Nathan Cleary, the Panthers star who has enjoyed a meteoric rise since breaking into the NRL in 2016. If Cleary can continue the upward trajectory he has enjoyed each year of his career, something special beckons in 2019. 

For the Panthers to win

Unity is a big word in team sport, and the unity among the Penrith players has been put to the test in recent weeks. On paper, they have a stronger squad than the Eels, so if they're playing with clear minds and a common purpose a win should follow.

For the Eels to win

If the Eels forwards can match it with their Penrith counterparts, it will be up to Clint Gutherson and Moses to work some magic with ball in hand. The pair are good enough to produce match-winning displays on their day. Eels fans are hoping such days come along with regularity in 2019.

And another thing ...

Blake Ferguson had a superb 2018, a string of performances he turned into a multi-year deal with the Eels. If he can replicate that form for his new club, the Eels will have gone a long way towards replacing Parramatta fan favourite Semi Radradra. A big ask, but Ferguson is good enough to make that happen.

Brett Kimmorley says ...

It is round one from last year all over again. It is important for the Penrith side to start playing from the start of games this year. New coach Ivan Cleary focuses on the little things and as a result, I expect Penrith to go really well in 2019. For Parra, Blake Ferguson will start sets really well and Junior Paulo is a big body in the middle, but they've got a rookie hooker and a rookie five-eighth. That puts a bit of pressure on them to start the year.
Panthers by 6

Stat Attack: Panthers

The Panthers topped the NRL missed tackle count in 2018. If they are to turn another season which features finals football into one which has them playing in the final match of the season, their tackling has to improve. It's as simple as that.

Stat Attack: Eels

Finishing with the wooden spoon in 2018 was the stat that still hurts the Eels the most. The fact they only just 15.8 points per game last year was a major contributor that woe. An improvement in that department is sure to lead to more wins.

Head to head in the NRL era (since 1998)

  • Played: 38; Panthers 19 wins, Eels 19 wins
  • Latest result: Panthers beat Eels 12-6 in round 5, 2018
  • At this venue: Panthers 55% wins, Eels 39% wins
Acknowledgement of Country

National Rugby League respects and honours the Traditional Custodians of the land and pay our respects to their Elders past, present and future. We acknowledge the stories, traditions and living cultures of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples on the lands we meet, gather and play on.

Premier Partner

Media Partners

Major Partners

View All Partners