You have skipped the navigation, tab for page content

The Panthers lost their first game and were hammered in their third game. They scraped home in rounds two and four before being upstaged by the previously winless Titans last week.

So what should we expect next from one of the so-called contenders for the 2019 premiership?

There were times early in the first half and early in the second when Penrith looked like they could almost do as they pleased against the Titans.

But they lost momentum and were unable to get it back against a side that looked like it had forgotten how to win in the first four rounds.

The injury-hit Sharks went down fighting against the Roosters last week and will be keen to kick the Panthers while they’re down.

The Rundown

Team news

Sharks: Will Kennedy comes in at fullback for his NRL debut in jersey No.19. Josh Dugan shifts to the wing and Sione Katoa is out of the side. Jayson Bukuya has been taken off the interchange bench and his spot goes to Braden Hamlin-Uele. Paul Gallen (ribs) is back to bolster the pack and Jack Williams goes back to the bench after starting for Gallen last week. Kyle Flanagan and Aaron Gray were omitted from the squad 24 hours prior to kick-off. Katoa and Bukuya were left out when the squad was finalised an hour before kick-off.

Panthers: In a late change, winger Dylan Edwards has been left out and his place taken by Malakai Watene-Zelezniak in jersey 20. Representative prop Reagan Campbell-Gillard has been relegated to the bench and his place in the starting line-up taken by Tim Grant, who returned from injury last week in Canterbury Cup. Wayde Egan returns from concussion in the hooking role with Sione Katoa reverting to the bench. Isaah Yeo has been cleared of a shoulder injury and will play. Tyrell Fuimaono and Jarome Luai were culled from the squad on Wednesday evening, with Liam Martin replacing Fuimaono on the interchange. 

Team Lists


  • Fullback for Sharks is number 19 William Kennedy
    Fullback for Panthers is number 1 Dallin Watene-Zelezniak
  • Winger for Sharks is number 1 Josh Dugan
    Winger for Panthers is number 2 Josh Mansour
  • Centre for Sharks is number 3 Bronson Xerri
    Centre for Panthers is number 3 Dean Whare
  • Centre for Sharks is number 4 Josh Morris
    Centre for Panthers is number 4 Waqa Blake
  • Winger for Sharks is number 2 Sosaia Feki
    Winger for Panthers is number 20 Malakai Watene-Zelezniak
  • Five-Eighth for Sharks is number 6 Shaun Johnson
    Five-Eighth for Panthers is number 6 James Maloney
  • Halfback for Sharks is number 7 Chad Townsend
    Halfback for Panthers is number 7 Nathan Cleary


  • Prop for Sharks is number 8 Andrew Fifita
    Prop for Panthers is number 8 James Tamou
  • Hooker for Sharks is number 9 Jayden Brailey
    Hooker for Panthers is number 9 Wayde Egan
  • Prop for Sharks is number 10 Matt Prior
    Prop for Panthers is number 10 Tim Grant
  • 2nd Row for Sharks is number 11 Briton Nikora
    2nd Row for Panthers is number 11 Viliame Kikau
  • 2nd Row for Sharks is number 12 Kurt Capewell
    2nd Row for Panthers is number 12 Isaah Yeo
  • Lock for Sharks is number 13 Paul Gallen
    Lock for Panthers is number 13 James Fisher-Harris


  • Interchange for Sharks is number 14 Blayke Brailey
    Interchange for Panthers is number 14 Sione Katoa
  • Interchange for Sharks is number 16 Jack Williams
    Interchange for Panthers is number 16 Moses Leota
  • Interchange for Sharks is number 17 Scott Sorensen
    Interchange for Panthers is number 17 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
  • Interchange for Sharks is number 20 Braden Hamlin-Uele
    Interchange for Panthers is number 19 Liam Martin

Match Officials

  • Referee: Ben Cummins
  • Referee: Ziggy Przeklasa-Adamski
  • Touch Judge: Phil Henderson
  • Touch Judge: Chris Sutton
  • Senior Review Official: Steve Chiddy

Last updated:

Key match-up

With both teams missing key players and carrying the odd injured soldier, a lot hinges on the battle between the opposing halves. Cronulla duo Chad Townsend and Shaun Johnson have to lead as always with strong actions and words, while Panthers halves James Maloney and Nathan Cleary are rapidly in need of some consistency if their team is going to prosper.

For the Sharks to win

Defence is always a high priority for the Sharks and they’ll have to be especially vigilant on the edges against the likes of Viliame Kikau and James Fisher-Harris. Keeping ex-Shark Maloney and Cleary relatively quiet is crucial, while the outside backs have to be on their toes against Penrith’s speedsters.

For the Panthers to win

Maybe losing to the NRL’s last-place team will jolt the Panthers into playing up to their potential. It really wasn’t all that surprising they lost to the Titans considering the form guide over the first month. Coach Ivan Cleary has to find a way to get his side to stop switching off during games.

Brett Kimmorley says

Confidence for both teams will be down a little bit. The Sharks are really being tested by all their injuries. A player that really needs to take control from them this week is Shaun Johnson. We still haven’t seen any sort of form from Penrith, they’ve been so disappointing considering the roster they’ve put together. Sharks by 4

Sharks Stat Attack

The Sharks lead the NRL in line breaks (25), line break assists (17) and off-loads (70) but they have also conceded more penalties (40) than any team.

Panthers Stat Attack

For a team that had struggled to find its offensive mojo, the Panthers scored a season-high 24 points from 33/39 completions last week against the Titans. The only problem was that their usually reliable defence went missing in the form of a staggering 67 missed tackles. No that’s not a misprint.

And another thing …

The Dragons continue to deny it but the rumour that Trent Merrin will re-join the club won’t go away. If things don’t work out with his former club, Merrin might be a good fit for the Sharks, who need to bolster their pack with age (Paul Gallen) and injuries (Wade Graham, Aaron Woods) taking a toll. If Merrin is prepared to play for peanuts for the rest of this season, there could be a decent payoff with the Sharks down the track.

Acknowledgement of Country

National Rugby League respects and honours the Traditional Custodians of the land and pay our respects to their Elders past, present and future. We acknowledge the stories, traditions and living cultures of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples on the lands we meet, gather and play on.

Premier Partner

Media Partners

Major Partners

View All Partners