You have skipped the navigation, tab for page content
Preliminary final player ratings: Canberra Raiders

Player ratings for the Canberra Raiders in their preliminary final clash with Melbourne Storm.

1. Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad: A tough night at the back. Marched backwards in defence too often. Never stopped trying but not able to have the same impact on the game he did in the semi-finals. 4/10

2. Semi Valemei: Given a torrid time under the high ball and caught out as Vunivalu scored the Storm's third try but produced some powerful runs in the second half. 4

3. Jarrod Croker: Missed a tackle on Vunivalu in the Storm winger's first half try and unsighted in attack. 3.5

Canberra halfback George Williams.
Canberra halfback George Williams. ©Scott Davis/NRL Photos

4. Jordan Rapana: Exposed badly at right centre in the Storm's opening two tries and some highly questionable moments in attack including some costly non-passes before eventually offloading for Cotric's second. Should be his last game as a centre. 3

5. Nick Cotric: Impressive work for Canberra's first try and some strong carries in the second half. Denied a second he should have scored by the old goat Cam Smith before nabbing a simple late consolation try. 6

6. Jack Wighton: Couldn't find the game-breaking moments he has been able to produce so often this year. Effort was there but very well contained. 4

7. George Williams: Kicking game was magnificent with some pinpoint shots to force three repeat sets and put it on a dime for Cotric's try. Running game dangerous in the second half. His team's best next to Bateman. 7.5

Rapana flicks a pass to Cotric for his second

8. Josh Papalii: Canberra's slow start wasn't his fault but nor was he able to stop it. A quiet game to finish a mighty year. 4.5

14. Siliva Havili: Caught on the hop as the Storm exploded out of the blocks and caught flat-footed on opening try. Was asked to stay out there longer than he probably should have been. 4

16. Hudson Young: A tireless 55-minute spell in the middle from the opening whistle. Almost 100 metres and 32 tackles. 7

11. John Bateman: Finishes his NRL career as the best player in a losing team. A constant headache with his running game, belligerent in defence. A high-class effort despite few opportunities. 7.5

12. Elliott Whitehead: Scratchy start to the game as the Storm bolted out of the blocks with some uncharacteristic errors as the game wore on. Not his night. 3.5

13. Joseph Tapine: No eye-catching moments this week but one of his team's busiest in terms of both runs and his team-high 39 tackles. Big effort in a losing cause. 7

Cotric gets one back for Canberra


9. Tom Starling: Bafflingly held back until well after half time. Added plenty of spark when he finally got on but it was just too late by then. 5

15. Dunamis Lui: Given just 25 minutes through the middle of the contest and bent the line with a few carries but no real impact on the contest. 4

10. Iosia Soliola: Sparingly used after reverting to the bench on game day with less than half an hour on field but was solid while on. 4

17. Corey Harawira-Naera: Added plenty of energy when injected midway through the first half and helped turn the tide Canberra's way for a brief period. 4.5


The views in this article do not necessarily express the opinions of the NRL, ARLC, NRL clubs or state associations.

Acknowledgement of Country

National Rugby League respects and honours the Traditional Custodians of the land and pay our respects to their Elders past, present and future. We acknowledge the stories, traditions and living cultures of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples on the lands we meet, gather and play on.

Premier Partner

Media Partners

Major Partners

View All Partners