Twenty two unanswered points inside the final 25 minutes saw the Eels overcome the Sea Eagles 36-20 on Friday night for a victory which keeps them in the hunt for a spot in the top four and leaves Manly's finals hopes on life support.
Maika Sivo scored twice inside the opening eight minutes to get Parramatta, who were without injured halfback Mitchell Moses, off to a flying start at 4 Pines Park, but it soon became a contest where the lead changed on numerous occasions as both side's enjoyed periods of dominance.
Trailing 20-14 with 28 minutes to go, the Eels powered back with tries to Waqa Blake, Gutherson, Will Penisini and Dylan Brown, to put the result beyond doubt.
After Sivo's early double, Manly seemed to click into gear, with converted tries to Tolutau Koula and Jason Saab, coupled a penalty goal in between, giving the hosts a 14-8 lead.
Sivo stuns the Sea Eagles
Tom Opacic's converted try made it 14-14 at the half, but Parra were then first to break in the second period when Christian Tuipulotu went over.
Another penalty saw Manly stretch their lead out to six, before a freakish finish from Blake in his 150th NRL match made it a two-point game.
Gutherson and Brown then raced away for long-range tries, with Penisini crossing in between, to give their side an important victory.
Brown sticks a dagger through the Sea Eagles
- Without halfback Mitchell Moses in the side, Eels playmaker Dylan Brown was outstanding, making 40 tackles and running for over 150 metres, to go with his try.
- Parramatta completed 88 percent of their sets at 4 Pines Park.
- Sea Eagles five-eighth Kieran Foran left the match near full-time with what coach Des Hasler said was a minor hamstring injury.
- Jason Saab was placed on report for a tackle with 14 minutes left in the match, putting a blemish on an otherwise strong night which included a try and 249 run metres.
- Eels forward Ryan Matterson left the field for an HIA 10 minutes before full-time.
- The win means the Eels have defeated the Sea Eagles twice in a season for the first time since 2016.
- Parramatta centre Waqa Blake marked his 150th NRL appearance with a stunning try in the second half.
Play of the game
A remarkable finish when the game sat in the balance. Blake showed incredible body control to get the ball down just before his knees hit the turf, for one of the finishes of the season.
Blake with the put down of the year
What they said
I thought we went in at half-time in pretty good shape, started the second half OK... but there was some tackles there we just had to make and didn't make them. We have got to win the next four from four [to make the finals]... I haven't done the math, but anything less is not going to work." - Sea Eagles coach Des Hasler.
Sea Eagles: Round 21
"I thought that we stayed in the fight [in the second half], because they came at us early and got a try. We came away with what was needed at the back end of that half. Thought our control was really good and our discipline was good" - Eels coach Brad Arthur.
Eels: Round 21
The Sea Eagles head up to Queensland to face the last-placed Titans at Cbus Super Stadium next Sunday, while Parramatta are at home to the Rabbitohs on Saturday.